U.S. needs more immigration, not less!
Nation already losing jobs for lack of educated workforce,
system to import top scientists, engineers to keep U.S. No. 1
By Ken Harvey
Largely because of the knee-jerk reaction of conservatives, Congress has again rejected the DREAM Act that would encourage top high school students whose parents brought them into the U.S. illegally to go to a university and become part of America’s efforts to retain its top billing in the world economy.
Contrary to common thinking, in order to remain No. 1, the U.S. doesn’t need LESS immigration but rather MORE. Yes, we need to be smart about it. Yes, we need to “recruit” the best and brightest people in the world to come to the U.S. and, thus, remain the brain center of the world economy. Yes, we need to seal the borders to both provide greater security and to reduce the drag on our social welfare programs. But after spending billions of tax dollars on educating the children of illegal immigrants, we also need to reap the rewards of that investment.
I am saying this as a conservative Republican who teaches journalism at an overseas university located very near to the two nations about to overtake the U.S. and very possibly reduce our nation to the No. 2 or No. 3 economic power in the world. KIMEP University, located in Almaty, Kazakhstan, is less than 100 miles from China and just a little north of India — the two nations positioning themselves to take over world economic leadership.
National pride is good, but to think the U.S. cannot lose its world status is dangerous. The world economy is ever more flat, and the dollar currently is in danger.
India has now has the largest English-speaking population in the world, and China wants to overtake them. India has more English-speaking university honors students than America has total university students. The U.S. should be recruiting the best students from throughout the world to come to our universities and to STAY in the U.S. We could still have millions of world applicants to choose from if we offered foreign graduates of U.S. universities a pathway to citizenship. But that window of opportunity is closing quickly.
Regardless, we certainly need to keep the honor students who are already here — whatever their parents’ status. But if we could deport all illegal aliens tomorrow, we would throw our own economy into a full depression. We would lose millions of valuable workers, not to mention consumers. The debate should be about how we can best cull the wheat from the chaff. How can we legalize productive illegal aliens and deport those who are unproductive, committing crimes or harming our society in other obvious ways.
Republicans are idiots for not catering to the fastest-growing segment of our population and appealing to common values that could help the party regain and maintain control over the next century.
Hispanics – if they retain the values of their older generation – are either Catholic or Evangelical. In either case, they tend to be anti-abortion and would side with Republicans on many other issues.
Hispanics are naturally entrepreneurial. It seems like nearly every Hispanic family has come up with some business to help enhance their income. Many are starting more formal establishments, such as restaurants and mechanic shops.
Hispanics believe in the American Dream, and they want a chance to achieve it. They should be Republicans.
It was President George W. Bush who brought them the No Child Left Behind Act that seriously forced the so-called liberal teachers to stop ignoring the ethnic kids sitting in the back of the room. As much as the liberal teacher’s union wanted to criticize the Bush Administration, once the Democrats got control of Congress, the migrant and bilingual educators rushed to Washington, D.C., to plead with the Democrats NOT to undo the positive aspects of the Republicans’ education reform.
Before the Bush reforms, researchers were able to show that despite BILLIONS of dollars in federal education aid, there was NO STATISTICAL EVIDENCE – I repeat: NO STATISTICAL EVIDENCE that any of it did any good. Graduation rates had not improved. National test scores had not improved. NO STATISTICAL EVIDENCE.
All that money did not good – until Republican reforms demanded statistical evidence that federal funds were actually helping children achieve success. The biggest complaint by the liberals who control education in the U.S. was that the Republican rules set the standards too high. But student achievement did begin going up all over the country. Most schools are able to show some achievement – just not as much as new regulations demanded.
But under the Democrats who controlled Congress most of the 20th Century before the Republicans’ Contract with America in 1994, nothing got done except money spent and Democratic union supporters rewarded.
The ethnic kids, whose parents trusted the Democrats to help the poor and struggling students, were falling further and further behind.
But despite these failures, who are Hispanics and other ethnic groups looking to for help? The do-nothing-but-throw-money-at-problems Democrats! The party that tends to be anti-business, pro-tax, pro-abortion – the opposite of what Hispanics want as they settle in the U.S. – and who can’t even develop welfare and education programs in ways that help rather hurt their own claimed constituency.
A major reason the Republicans are losing the Hispanic vote is immigration reform and the “ship them all back” stance taken by many Republicans.
If you want to see the current Great Recession turn into another Great Depression, send all the hard-working Hispanics back. To even talk about sending the 15-20 million illegal Hispanics back makes no pragmatic sense.
It may be in line with Republicans’ pro law-and-order values, but it is really anti-business. I grew up the son of a struggling farmer. If hard-nose Republicans could have done want they want to do now, they would have put Dad and many other small farmers out of business.
Such Republicans want to refer to limited anecdotal evidence that some non-Hispanics would actually take jobs picking apples, cutting asparagus, hoeing weeds, and working in the agricultural packing plants for what the ag industry can afford to pay.
Farmers are probably 80 percent Republican, but if you asked them if they think they could replace illegal farm laborers with legal ones, I guarantee that over 90 percent would not only say “no,” they would laugh and declare “hell, no!”
The federal government estimates that in order to replace the retiring baby-boomers, not only should the U.S. NOT “send them all back” but should import nearly another million immigrants every year.
Many of those million should be the best and brightest. According to a senior vice president for Microsoft, the U.S. is losing thousands of jobs already for lack of enough employees educated in math, science and technology.
His company has imported employees from 144 different countries, but the lack of a trained workforce and the inability of Congress to pass immigration reform have forced Microsoft to open a plant in Vancouver, B.C., says Brad Smith, the company’s senior vice president, general counsel and corporate secretary.
“The reality is, we’re having to move jobs,” Smith says, “because this country is not producing enough engineers and the immigration laws are tightening.”
In talking to people throughout the computer industry it is clear, he says, that “many of our best jobs will leave this country” if the U.S. fails to prepare a new generation of people who have those skills or opens its doors to immigrants who do.
Improved technological skills are needed throughout the economy, says Smith. Today, even mechanics and construction managers need technology skills to succeed.
If Republicans are going to continue supporting free trade, the U.S. to find its niche in the world economy. Our niche will not longer be manufacturing. Those jobs will go to countries with cheaper labor.
America’s future must be to lead the world in education, research, and the information industry. To avoid losing our position as the world’s greatest nation, we MUST begin actively importing the best and brightest from all over the world because despite our ethnocentric self-deception that the best and brightest are all in American schools, Smith and other business executives have had to face the hard reality that it just isn’t so.
And which is the fastest-growing group in American students who have a chance to replace at least some of those retiring baby-boomers? The Hispanic kids. That’s why Bush’s education reform was so essential to ALL Americans. We need those kids to become productive adults – no matter what color or ethnicity they may be.
American children will increasingly have to compete for employment with the children in India, China and other parts of the world.
His is a company that has to “re-invent” itself every few years in order to survive. He notes that new products frequently “fail” and lose money for seven years before they achieve success. Like Microsoft, he says, the U.S. has to be willing to invest in its future.
“Change requires a commitment and requires a vision. If our kids aren’t worth it, nothing is. All of us need to stand up together for our kids and for our future,” Smith says.
Washington congressman promotes immigration reform
He’s a Democrat, but Republicans need to think real hard about what U.S. Rep. Adam Smith of Washington State has to say about immigration reform.
“I don’t agree with those out there who think America can’t compete. … I don’t believe that for a second,” he says. “We still have the best economic system the world has ever seen. The global economy is much more competitive than it used to be. So we have to be smarter about where we have a competitive advantage.”
While U.S. schools and colleges need to provide the skills people need to compete, he says that won’t be enough.
“We need to recognize the importance of immigration. What makes our country great and has made it great for so many years is that people from all over the world, representing all sorts of countries and all colors, ethnicities and religions want to come here. They love this place. They see this as the land of opportunity,” Smith says.
“Our entire country benefits from the energy, enthusiasm and work ethic that immigrants bring to this country,” he says. “They work hard and help make our society and our communities better places to live.
“People complain about illegal immigration, but we do not have enough immigration at this time,” Smith says. “If we allowed more of it and had an easier system to get into this country, we wouldn’t have as many undocumented problems as we do.
“The economic opportunity in this country, in contrast with the lack of economic opportunity in other countries, makes people want to come here. We have a lot of undocumented people now in this country, but we need to get it into our minds that, by and large, these people aren’t doing anything much different than citizens. They are students; they are workers. Some of them do bad things; a lot of them do good things. They are part of our community and part of our society,” he says.
Congressman Smith adds that one of the biggest problems in fixing the immigration law is the large and vociferous segment that has declared essentially that unless the U.S. gets every undocumented immigrant out of the country and doesn’t allow any more to come in, there can be no reform.
“To begin with, that’s impossible,” he says. “You simply can’t take 15 million people in the United States who you can’t identify and send them back anywhere. Also, it wouldn’t be good for us. It wouldn’t be good for anybody. A whole lot of those 15 million people are doing very vital, very important things in our community. So it would be bad for the rest of us if they left. We have to get that message through.”
In addition, the U.S. has essentially already invested billions of dollars in preparing the children of the undocumented immigrants to replace the baby-boomers.
“These children have lived in our society, gone to school and played with neighborhood children, and then after they’ve been educated and get out of high school, we tell them, ‘No, you can’t be part of our society. We aren’t going to let you go to college.’ That is not smart policy,” Smith says.
“That is a detriment to this country, not to mention a detriment to the children who worked so hard to get to the point where they could go to college.”
America’s successful history was due to the most hard-working, innovative, daring people of the world coming here. Yes, we have a lot of natural resources in the U.S., but our most valuable resources have always been our human resources – the Jamestown settlers, the Pilgrims, the Founding Father themselves, the pioneers, the risk-it-all gold diggers…
And our ability to attract the best and brightest has been more due to the magnificent system of freedom and opportunity our Founding Fathers gave us than our natural resources.
Republicans should be the Hispanics’ best friends – legitimately and sincerely. The fact that Hispanics will soon make up 25 percent of the American population makes it a smart move, but it’s the right move anyway.
At http://Virtual-Institute.us are stories about some of those Hispanic immigrants. Read and hear their stories and ask yourself if they shouldn’t be Republicans, if they’re not already.